Jennifer’s Secret: The Rabbit and the Buried Past

🔴 JENNIFER JUST SAID SHE KNOWS ABOUT THE RABBIT, BUT I HAVEN’T BOUGHT ONE.

I choked on my coffee when Jennifer looked right at me and asked if “he” was comfortable in his new cage. The air in the kitchen felt thick, like a wet blanket, and I swear I could taste metal.

“What rabbit?” I finally croaked, and she just smiled this tiny, sad little smile. I’ve never seen her look at me like that. It felt like a punch to the gut — worse than when Dad told me he was leaving.

It’s been years since I had a pet, and even longer since I spoke to Greg — my old college roommate who called me “Rabbit” as a joke. It was all about this embarrassing story from freshman year. The one about the bunny costume. The bunny I definitely burned a decade ago.

I don’t know what’s going on. She knows something, and it’s something old. Something buried. She smells like lemons, and the sun through the window is blinding.

👇 Full story continued in the comments…
My legs felt weak, like I might crumple right there in the kitchen. The clock on the microwave ticked, each second a hammer blow against my skull. I needed to get out, to think.

“I… I have to go,” I stammered, pushing past Jennifer. Her eyes followed me, that unsettling sadness still clinging to them.

I bolted out the back door, the fresh air stinging my lungs. I didn’t even grab my keys. My car sat in the driveway, mocking me. I needed to calm down. I ran around the yard, a frantic circle, my mind a whirlwind. The bunny costume, the bunny I destroyed – it all bubbled back up. It had been a terrible, drunken night. A dare. The costume, the party… the bonfire.

And Greg. Greg who knew too much.

I took a deep breath and went back inside, finding Jennifer exactly where I left her, by the stove, stirring something in a pot. The scent of lemons was even stronger now.

“Jennifer, what are you talking about?” I asked, trying to sound steady, but my voice cracked.

She finally turned, and the sadness was gone, replaced by a chilling calmness. Her eyes, though the same color as always, seemed to have deepened, like looking into a still, dark pond. “It’s about Greg. And the rabbit, of course.”

She gestured to the pot, now simmering, releasing a steam that smelled like… burning hay? No. Something else. Something… familiar.

“He… he told me everything. About the accident.” Her voice was a whisper, but it cut through the silence like a knife.

Accident? What accident? I didn’t remember an accident. Suddenly, the memory slammed into me, a torrent of images: the party, the costume, stumbling out into the woods… then darkness. Then… Greg. Greg frantically trying to hide something.

The rabbit. The real rabbit. The one I hadn’t seen. The one Greg had cared for. The one that had been in the car with me that night.

Jennifer smiled, a full, terrifying smile this time. “He survived, you know. The rabbit. Greg took care of him. And now… it’s time he sees you.”

She lifted the pot from the stove, the steam now thick with the sickly sweet smell of… something fleshy. “He’s in the basement, waiting for you.” She pointed towards the cellar door. “He missed you. You can’t leave now, not until you acknowledge him and what you did.”

I stumbled back, the world tilting on its axis. The truth, dark and terrible, had finally surfaced. I was no longer sure what I had burned a decade ago. And in the humid air of the kitchen, with the smell of burnt hay and lemons clinging to the air, I knew I had no choice. I turned and went down the stairs, the darkness of the cellar a gaping maw, waiting to swallow me whole.